
• 一Waymo乘客表示,自己搭乘的无人出租车原地转了八圈,导致自己差点没赶上飞机。 一段视频显示,Waymo 客服在该车出现故障时未能帮助停下车辆,该事件引起了人们对自动驾驶安全性的担忧。
或许你也担心过无人出租车出现失控情况,而你最害怕的这一幕就发生在了Waymo一位乘客的身上。
迈克·约翰斯是一位来自加利福尼亚州英格尔伍德的人工智能顾问,日前他在领英上发文,讲述了自己在赫兹汽车停车场搭乘Waymo无人出租车前往菲尼克斯天港国际机场过程中经历的一起车辆失控事件。 他发布的视频显示,车辆一直在停车场原地打转。
“为什么我会在周一遇到这种事?”约翰斯在视频中说道,“为什么这玩意一直在转圈?我都要晕了。”
在车子刚转了几圈时,约翰斯还以为自己是被恶搞了。
约翰斯对《财富》杂志说:“我当时还以为是某个朋友在玩SNL上常见的那种把戏。我有几个朋友就喜欢这么干。 结果事实并非如此。 然后我的反应就变成了:这到底怎么回事? 我是碰上拍电影了么?”
约翰斯告诉《财富》,这并非他首次搭乘Waymo无人出租车。 约翰斯之前有过一次“非常短暂”的Waymo搭乘经历,但他想再试一次,“因为自动驾驶汽车是未来发展的方向,而创造未来要从现在开始”。
然后,车里突然传来了Waymo客服的声音,在公司了解到该车失控的情况后,该客服开始通过车内喇叭与约翰斯通话,但她也无法停下车辆,她表示,该车“路由可能出了问题”。
约翰斯对客服说:“这辆车一直在停车场内转圈。我系上了安全带,不能下车。这车是被黑了吗?发生了什么事? 我还要赶飞机呢。”
约翰斯说,他感觉客服不像“真人”,或者说更像个AI机器人,因为对他有关乘车的具体问题,客服都是避而不答。 由于当时他是要去机场赶飞机,他就问了客服,如果自己因此次故障错过航班,Waymo是否会赔偿机票费用,但该客服并未回答他的问题。
约翰斯说:“这个客服没提供多少有用信息,让我觉得她好像只是在根据提示机械地回答问题。如果你问的问题超出了设计范围,她就不知道该说什么了。”
约翰斯在领英贴文中写道,车子一共绕了八圈,导致他差点错过航班。他录制的视频显示,客服表示其没有控制汽车的选项,但“正尝试让车停下来”。该客服还指示约翰斯用手机上的应用来解决问题。
约翰斯说:“真正让我火大的就是她的这段话,因为我觉得这是你们公司和这辆车的问题,不是我手机的问题。” 他说,解决这个问题大约花了五到七分钟,不过因为事出突然,所以感觉上花的时间要更长。
Waymo并未立即回应《财富》杂志的置评请求。
“Waymo的乘坐体验糟透了,”约翰斯在帖文中写道。“以后我还是回归传统,只坐#Lyft 或#Uber算了”。
JW Surety Bonds发布的一项研究显示,在无人出租车技术不断发展的同时,愿意选择无人出租车来代替传统共享汽车的美国人却仅占25%。
约翰斯还在帖文中写道,Waymo没有通过电子邮件、短信或电话来跟进他的情况。他写道:“啥都没有,客服都是AI运营的自动化服务。”
不过,Waymo在接受美国有线电视新闻网(CNN)采访时表示,该公司曾尝试过联系约翰斯,并留下了语音邮件进行跟进。约翰斯向《财富》杂志再次表明,Waymo采取的唯一补救措施就是退还了自己的车费。
约翰斯对《财富》杂志说:“我还没跟他们有过任何交流。这种体验很糟糕,因为在这样一个自动化风行、全面数字化的时代,人与机器的共生关系仍需保持平衡。”
无人出租车的未来
这一事件引发了人们对Waymo安全性的质疑。 不过,据美联社(The Associated Press)报道,截至12月初,Waymo在每周提供超过15万次出行服务的情况下,“没有发生过任何灾难性交通事故”。 而且,根据本周发布的安全影响报告,截至2024年9月,Waymo汽车已经在没有人类驾驶员的情况下行驶了3300万英里。
虽然约翰斯的经历算不上“事故”,看起来也没有造成人员伤亡,但却足以令人感到震惊和迷惑。
约翰斯在帖文中写道:“这辆无人汽车对GPS完全置之不理。感觉就像科幻惊悚片里的场景。”
虽然Waymo的事故纪录还算良好,但公开信息显示,这家位于加州山景城的公司(前身是谷歌的自动驾驶汽车项目)曾于2024年6月召回672辆汽车,以便降低撞上电线杆的可能(此前一月有一辆Waymo发生过此类事故)。 Waymo 此前还进行过数次召回,比如在2024年2月,其旗下两辆汽车于几分钟内撞上同一卡车,事故发生后该公司就进行过召回。 去年春天,Waymo和另一家无人出租车公司Zoox因旗下车辆不稳定、意料之外的自动驾驶行为而遭到联邦调查。
约翰斯还提到了在使用在研技术时会遇到的挑战。
约翰斯告诉《财富》:“我相当于付费参加了一项实验。因为在我们乘坐此类车辆时,每发生一次错误,他们都要花我们的钱来修复错误。”
不过,Waymo 声称,“截至目前的数据表明,在我们目前运营的地区,Waymo Driver的存在已使交通事故伤亡情况有效改善。Waymo致力于通过安全和负责任的驾驶行为来减少交通伤亡,并将在扩大运营规模的同时谨慎管理风险。”
投资者依然看好自动驾驶技术的未来。2024年10月,Waymo从投资者处筹集了56亿美元,这也是该公司迄今为止规模最大的一轮融资。 Waymo车载技术工程主管斯里坎斯 ·蒂鲁玛拉此前告诉《财富》记者谢丽尔·埃斯特拉达,为与潜在客户建立信任,该公司在宣传中会优先介绍自身的安全性。
蒂鲁玛拉说:“我们还是希望外界把焦点放在我们实际在做的事情上。作为行业领导者,我们必须以负责任的态度开发这项技术”。(财富中文网)
译者:梁宇
审校:夏林
• 一Waymo乘客表示,自己搭乘的无人出租车原地转了八圈,导致自己差点没赶上飞机。 一段视频显示,Waymo 客服在该车出现故障时未能帮助停下车辆,该事件引起了人们对自动驾驶安全性的担忧。
或许你也担心过无人出租车出现失控情况,而你最害怕的这一幕就发生在了Waymo一位乘客的身上。
迈克·约翰斯是一位来自加利福尼亚州英格尔伍德的人工智能顾问,日前他在领英上发文,讲述了自己在赫兹汽车停车场搭乘Waymo无人出租车前往菲尼克斯天港国际机场过程中经历的一起车辆失控事件。 他发布的视频显示,车辆一直在停车场原地打转。
“为什么我会在周一遇到这种事?”约翰斯在视频中说道,“为什么这玩意一直在转圈?我都要晕了。”
在车子刚转了几圈时,约翰斯还以为自己是被恶搞了。
约翰斯对《财富》杂志说:“我当时还以为是某个朋友在玩SNL上常见的那种把戏。我有几个朋友就喜欢这么干。 结果事实并非如此。 然后我的反应就变成了:这到底怎么回事? 我是碰上拍电影了么?”
约翰斯告诉《财富》,这并非他首次搭乘Waymo无人出租车。 约翰斯之前有过一次“非常短暂”的Waymo搭乘经历,但他想再试一次,“因为自动驾驶汽车是未来发展的方向,而创造未来要从现在开始”。
然后,车里突然传来了Waymo客服的声音,在公司了解到该车失控的情况后,该客服开始通过车内喇叭与约翰斯通话,但她也无法停下车辆,她表示,该车“路由可能出了问题”。
约翰斯对客服说:“这辆车一直在停车场内转圈。我系上了安全带,不能下车。这车是被黑了吗?发生了什么事? 我还要赶飞机呢。”
约翰斯说,他感觉客服不像“真人”,或者说更像个AI机器人,因为对他有关乘车的具体问题,客服都是避而不答。 由于当时他是要去机场赶飞机,他就问了客服,如果自己因此次故障错过航班,Waymo是否会赔偿机票费用,但该客服并未回答他的问题。
约翰斯说:“这个客服没提供多少有用信息,让我觉得她好像只是在根据提示机械地回答问题。如果你问的问题超出了设计范围,她就不知道该说什么了。”
约翰斯在领英贴文中写道,车子一共绕了八圈,导致他差点错过航班。他录制的视频显示,客服表示其没有控制汽车的选项,但“正尝试让车停下来”。该客服还指示约翰斯用手机上的应用来解决问题。
约翰斯说:“真正让我火大的就是她的这段话,因为我觉得这是你们公司和这辆车的问题,不是我手机的问题。” 他说,解决这个问题大约花了五到七分钟,不过因为事出突然,所以感觉上花的时间要更长。
Waymo并未立即回应《财富》杂志的置评请求。
“Waymo的乘坐体验糟透了,”约翰斯在帖文中写道。“以后我还是回归传统,只坐#Lyft 或#Uber算了”。
JW Surety Bonds发布的一项研究显示,在无人出租车技术不断发展的同时,愿意选择无人出租车来代替传统共享汽车的美国人却仅占25%。
约翰斯还在帖文中写道,Waymo没有通过电子邮件、短信或电话来跟进他的情况。他写道:“啥都没有,客服都是AI运营的自动化服务。”
不过,Waymo在接受美国有线电视新闻网(CNN)采访时表示,该公司曾尝试过联系约翰斯,并留下了语音邮件进行跟进。约翰斯向《财富》杂志再次表明,Waymo采取的唯一补救措施就是退还了自己的车费。
约翰斯对《财富》杂志说:“我还没跟他们有过任何交流。这种体验很糟糕,因为在这样一个自动化风行、全面数字化的时代,人与机器的共生关系仍需保持平衡。”
无人出租车的未来
这一事件引发了人们对Waymo安全性的质疑。 不过,据美联社(The Associated Press)报道,截至12月初,Waymo在每周提供超过15万次出行服务的情况下,“没有发生过任何灾难性交通事故”。 而且,根据本周发布的安全影响报告,截至2024年9月,Waymo汽车已经在没有人类驾驶员的情况下行驶了3300万英里。
虽然约翰斯的经历算不上“事故”,看起来也没有造成人员伤亡,但却足以令人感到震惊和迷惑。
约翰斯在帖文中写道:“这辆无人汽车对GPS完全置之不理。感觉就像科幻惊悚片里的场景。”
虽然Waymo的事故纪录还算良好,但公开信息显示,这家位于加州山景城的公司(前身是谷歌的自动驾驶汽车项目)曾于2024年6月召回672辆汽车,以便降低撞上电线杆的可能(此前一月有一辆Waymo发生过此类事故)。 Waymo 此前还进行过数次召回,比如在2024年2月,其旗下两辆汽车于几分钟内撞上同一卡车,事故发生后该公司就进行过召回。 去年春天,Waymo和另一家无人出租车公司Zoox因旗下车辆不稳定、意料之外的自动驾驶行为而遭到联邦调查。
约翰斯还提到了在使用在研技术时会遇到的挑战。
约翰斯告诉《财富》:“我相当于付费参加了一项实验。因为在我们乘坐此类车辆时,每发生一次错误,他们都要花我们的钱来修复错误。”
不过,Waymo 声称,“截至目前的数据表明,在我们目前运营的地区,Waymo Driver的存在已使交通事故伤亡情况有效改善。Waymo致力于通过安全和负责任的驾驶行为来减少交通伤亡,并将在扩大运营规模的同时谨慎管理风险。”
投资者依然看好自动驾驶技术的未来。2024年10月,Waymo从投资者处筹集了56亿美元,这也是该公司迄今为止规模最大的一轮融资。 Waymo车载技术工程主管斯里坎斯 ·蒂鲁玛拉此前告诉《财富》记者谢丽尔·埃斯特拉达,为与潜在客户建立信任,该公司在宣传中会优先介绍自身的安全性。
蒂鲁玛拉说:“我们还是希望外界把焦点放在我们实际在做的事情上。作为行业领导者,我们必须以负责任的态度开发这项技术”。(财富中文网)
译者:梁宇
审校:夏林
• A Waymo customer said his self-driving taxi drove him around in eight circles, almost making him late for his flight. A video shows Waymo’s customer service wasn’t able to do much to stop the vehicle, raising concerns about self-driving safety.
If you’ve ever worried about a robotaxi going rogue, one Waymo customer has lived your worst nightmare.
Mike Johns, an artificial intelligence consultant from Inglewood, Calif., recounted in a LinkedIn post a disorienting experience riding in a Waymo, a self-driving cab, in a Hertz car parking lot to catch a ride to the Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport airport. He posted a video showing the vehicle driving around in circles in a parking lot.
“Why is this happening to me on a Monday?” Johns said in the video. “Why is this thing going in a circle? I’m getting dizzy.”
After the first couple of circles, Johns thought he was being pranked.
“I’m thinking it’s one of my friends doing some SNL skit,” Johns told Fortune. “I have a couple of friends like that. And lo and behold, that’s not the case. It now turns from that scenario into a: What the hell is going on? Am I in a movie?”
This wasn’t the first time Johns had ridden in a Waymo, he told Fortune. Johns had taken a Waymo for a “very short ride” one other time, but wanted to try it again “being that autonomous vehicles are the future, and that future starts now,” he said.
Then “all of a sudden” a Waymo customer support agent started speaking with Johns over the car speakers after the company was notified of the issue, but the agent could do little to stop the car from circling, saying it may be experiencing a “routing issue.”
“It’s circling around a parking lot. I got my seatbelt on. I can’t get out of the car,” Johns said to the agent. “Has this been hacked? What’s going on? I got a flight to catch.”
Johns said he felt as if the customer service agent was likely a “fake human” or AI-powered bot because they avoided answering specific questions pertaining to his ride. Since he was on the way to the airport, he asked whether Waymo would cover his flight if he missed it due to the debacle, and the customer service agent appeared to dodge his question.
“She doesn’t really say anything, which made me feel like this was just prompted, scripted type play,” Johns said. “If you ask something that’s not in that queue, it just doesn’t know what to say.”
Johns wrote in his LinkedIn post the car circled eight times in total, causing him to nearly miss his flight. The video shows the customer service agent said they didn’t have the option to control the car, but that they were “trying to pull it over.” The agent also instructs Johns to use his app to solve the problem.
“That’s where I get pissed, because I’m like, this problem is between you and the car, not my phone,” Johns said. It took about five-to-seven minutes to solve the problem, he said, which felt like longer than that because of how unexpected it was.
Waymo didn’t immediately respond to Fortune’s request for comment.
“My Waymo experience sucked,” Johns wrote in his post. “I’ll keep it old fashion and just #Lyft or #Uber.”
As self-driving taxis continue to be a burgeoning technology, only 25% of Americans would prefer a robotaxi to traditional rideshare, according to a study by JW Surety Bonds released Monday.
Johns also wrote in his post that Waymo had not followed up with him about the situation via email, text, or call. “Nope, customer service is automated and ran by AI,” he wrote.
Waymo, however, told CNN it attempted to contact Johns and left a voicemail for follow-up. Johns reiterated to Fortune that the only thing Waymo has done to remedy the situation is to refund him for his ride.
“I haven’t had any communication with them,” Johns told Fortune. “And that sucks, because in this age of automation, everything digitized, there still needs to be the balance of the symbiotic relationship between human and robot.”
The future of self-driving taxis
The incident raises questions about Waymo’s safety. As of early December, however, Waymo was providing more than 150,000 weekly trips “without any history of catastrophic traffic accidents,” according to The Associated Press. And, as of September 2024, Waymo cars had driven 33 million rider-only miles without a human driver, according to its Safety Impact report released this week.
While Johns’ experience wasn’t an accident and didn’t appear to cause injuries, it was jarring and disorienting.
“This autonomous vehicle said to heck with GPS,” Johns wrote in his post. “It felt like a scene in a sci fi thriller.”
Although Waymo hasn’t reported a history of accidents, the Mountain View, Calif. company, formerly Google’s self-driving car project, recalled 672 cars in June 2024 to make them less likely to drive into poles after a car struck one a month prior. Waymo issued other recalls, including in February 2024 when two of its cars hit the same truck just minutes apart. The company, along with other robotaxi company Zoox, was the target of a federal investigation last spring for erratic and “unexpected” self-driving behavior.
Johns also notes the challenges in using developing technology.
“I participated in an experiment in which I had to pay for,” Johns told Fortune. “Because what happens is, when you’re in these type of vehicles, is every error that happens, they work to fix the bugs on your dime.”
Waymo, however, claims “data to date indicates the Waymo Driver is already reducing traffic injuries and fatalities in the places where we currently operate,” according to the company’s safety page. “At Waymo, we aim to reduce traffic injuries and fatalities by driving safely and responsibly, and will carefully manage risk as we scale our operations.”
Investors remain optimistic about self-driving’s future. In October 2024, Waymo raised $5.6 billion from investors, its largest funding round yet. Srikanth Thirumalai, Waymo’s head of engineering for onboard technology, previously told Fortune’s Sheryl Estrada the company is prioritizing safety in its messaging to build trust with potential customers.
“We don’t want to take the focus off of what we’re actually trying to do here,” Thirumalai said. “We have to lead with ‘hey, we are developing this technology responsibly.’”